by Tim Grieve
Who made her cry?
We may have reached a new low here: Partisans are arguing over who made Samuel Alito's wife cry, and some in the press are acting like the episode actually matters.
"Alito Wife Leaves Hearing in Tears After Dem Attack," Matt Drudge screamed Wednesday. It was true, technically speaking. Martha-Ann Bomgardner did indeed walk out of the hearing room Wednesday, and she was a little choked up. And her departure did indeed come "after" Democrats pressed Alito to come clean about Concerned Alumni of Princeton. But Bomgardner's departure came during questioning from a Republican, South Carolina Sen. Lindsey Graham. Graham asked Alito, facetiously, if he was a "closet bigot," then said that he was "sorry" that Alito and his family have "had to sit here and listen to" the Democrats' charges about CAP. Something in there -- plus a migraine, maybe -- seems to have set Bomgardner off. Partisans on the right say that it's the Democrats' fault. Partisans on the left say it's Graham's.
Is this what we've come to? We suppose that some folks will view Alito's wife, and by extension Alito himself, with a little more sympathy now than they would have otherwise. But it's hard to see how Bomgardner's tears are some sort of watershed event -- at least unless you toil in the fields of TV news, where emotional images are what it's all about. "Maybe Martha-Ann Alito's tearful exit from the hearing room yesterday will do for the relentless partisanship in Washington what the Abramoff plea has done for the downward spiral on ethics: inspire introspection and a rush to demonstrate a change of behavior," the NBC News crew writes in this morning's First Read. "Between the partisan rancor on display during the Alito hearings, and mounting examples of public servants forgetting their mandate, the time is ripe for a lot of hand-wringing inside the Beltway over how fetid the atmosphere here has become."
NBC says that Bomgardner's teary exit may become "the seminal moment" in her husband's confirmation hearings, a hyperbolic conclusion that leaves us thinking about something they say at the beginning of each Supreme Court session: "God save the United States and this honorable court."
Contributors
Links
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2006
(1766)
-
▼
January
(93)
- Aide: Reagan Warned Before Beirut Blast
- As Usual, What Digby Said
- The case for impeachment
- The Myth of the American Political "Center" and th...
- Spies, Lies and Wiretaps
- Mike Huckabee Lost 110 Pounds. Ask Him How.
- The truth about The State Of Our Union
- Mr. Abramoff's Meetings, Again
- Feinstein: I'll back the filibuster after all
- Fw: Driven by Fear or Governed by Law?- FCNL
- Filibuster Now! Alito Is Un-American
- Murtha Says Iraq Is Now A "Civil War"
- Fw: Filibuster
- Senators in Need of A Spine
- Kerry to push for Alito filibuster
- How do you like your democracy now, Mr. Bush?
- Reid: Bush Has Made America Less Safe
- Bush Was Also Warned Before 9/11
- Gore Said What Needed To Be Said
- Impeachment hearings: The White House prepares for...
- Bush's PR Blitz Fizzles Under The Facts
- I ... Can't ... Take It ... Anymore
- Banking on the 'bank shot'
- Fw: Patriot Act: Call Your Members of Congress thi...
- Halliburton Cited In Iraq Contamination
- College Funds or Yacht Funds?
- My Right to Roe
- Activists seek to seize Souter's home
- Sounds like the ol' Kenny-boy line to me.....
- Sweet Victory: Progressive Caucuses Sweep the States
- Judge Alito's Radical Views
- Samuel Alito and CAP
- Truthiness 101: From Frey to Alito - New York Time...
- Goodbye, Democracy...Or Who Loves Ya, Ohio?
- Why America Has to Be Fat
- A tip for the cowardly press corps
- U.S. Obtains Internet Users' Search Records
- Could there still be a filibuster in Alito's future?
- Liberals haven't failed to capture Bin Laden
- K Street
- Hardball Scandal: Bin Laden=Michael Moore
- Google resists U.S. subpoena of search data
- Breaking Ranks
- Newt's New Con
- Right Smears Veteran Murtha Without A Qualm
- Bush turns coward against the Brady Bunch of Evil ...
- Strange Bedfellows v. Bush and Cheney
- Al Gore, Hillary Clinton and the GOP blow-back
- Iran issues stark warning on oil price
- Sen. Clinton slams Bush administration
- 10 Things Martin Luther King Would Have Done About...
- Text of Gore speech
- Judicial Gag Rule - New York TimesThe New York Tim...
- "Those Who Would Give Up Liberty For Security Dese...
- Glum Democrats Can't See Halting Bush on Courts - ...
- The Imperial Presidency at Work
- Bush Authorized Domestic Spying Before 9/11
- Who made her cry?
- The President Is Not Entitled To His Nominee
- Shifting the Burden
- Pelosi Wants Probe of "Corrupt Congress"
- Elizabeth Holtzman-from Nixon to Bush & the Case F...
- Alito and his coaches
- Attention, Medicare Shoppers . . . - New York Time...
- Alito falters on CAP
- Alito's "Open Mind"
- Alito hearings
- Alito hearings
- Alito hearings
- Alito hearings
- Alito hearings
- NSA Whistleblower Alleges Illegal Spying
- Personal: EPIC vs MedicareRX
- From Alito, a dodge on the details
- Cost of Iraq war could top $2 trillion - study
- Dean / Blitzer on Late Edition
- The Case Against Alito
- The Pentagon As FEMA or Bush IS the Anti-Christ
- But the President Insists That It's Legal; He's Ju...
- Among the myths and lies that get flattened . . .
- Noam Chomsky: A Tale of Two Quagmires
- Need Medicaid? Show Your Passport - New York Times...
- Bush Ignored Explicit Warnings In 2002 About Mine ...
- Debunking Bush's NSA Lies: A Handy Pocket Guide
- Iran in the Crosshairs
- For Principles or Profit?
- January 2, 2006"Old Half-Witted Sheep"A New York T...
- Student Punished for Refusing to Stand for the Ple...
- Bush's Macho Swagger is Back. But for How Long?
- Eat The Poor
- The Bush Family Coup
- social secuity
- George W. Bush as the New Richard Nixon
-
▼
January
(93)
No comments:
Post a Comment