Contributors
Links
Friday, August 25, 2006
Warantless Wiretap Program in Doubt
by Helen Thomas
WASHINGTON - "There are no hereditary kings in America and no powers not created in the Constitution."
That eloquent putdown of an imperial presidency was the essence of a ruling by U.S. District Judge Anna Diggs Taylor, who declared President Bush's warrantless wiretap program was unconstitutional.
Bush secretly authorized the intercepts after the 9/11 terrorist attacks, with the stated goal of eavesdropping on international calls and e-mails by potential al-Qaida terrorists. Existence of the program was revealed by The New York Times on Dec. 16.
After Taylor's decision, Bush immediately announced he would appeal. On Monday, he told reporters, "It was a terrible opinion. ... "
The ruling was made in a lawsuit brought by the ACLU and others representing scholars and journalists.
Taylor said the government surveillance program run by the National Security Agency violates privacy and free speech rights under the Bill of Rights. She also found the telephone taps violate the 1978 Federal Intelligence Surveillance Act, which requires court approval before the government can wiretap within the U.S.
"It was never the intent of the framers (of the U.S. Constitution) to give the president such unfettered control, particularly when such actions blatantly disregard the parameters clearly enumerated in the Bill of Rights," Taylor said.
The administration argued the 2001 congressional resolution authorizing the use of force -- passed after the terrorist attacks -- gave Bush the right to create the program. But Taylor noted the congressional resolution "says nothing whatsoever of intelligence or surveillance.
"
Both sides agreed to a temporary stay of her order halting government wiretapping until a Sept. 7 hearing.
It is odd that the administration finds the FISA law so burdensome, since obtaining a warrant should be no problem even in an emergency. The record shows the special court created by FISA almost always approves requests for electronic eavesdropping. The law also allows for retroactive approval in emergencies.
The alleged plot foiled in Britain to bomb airliners bound for the U.S. undoubtedly bolsters the administration's warnings about terrorism but still does not explain why the Bush administration balks at getting a warrant to spy legally.
Taylor's arguments have been trashed by some law school professors. Even some who agreed with her bottom-line ruling took issue with her reasoning and rhetoric.
But to an average American, the ruling's beauty rests in its simplicity and the inspiration that the Constitution still prevails.
Anthony Romero, the ACLU executive director, said the ruling vindicates the notion there are limits on the scope of executive authority.
"Ultimately," Romero added, "any doubts about the decision will be taken on appeal by sitting federal judges rather than pundits or commentators."
Last February, the American Bar Association adopted a resolution calling on the president "to abide by the limitations which the Constitution imposes on a president under our system of checks and balances and respect the essential roles of the Congress and the judicial branch in ensuring that our national security is protected in a manner consistent with constitutional guarantees."
The ABA urged the president to seek appropriate legislation, rather than act outside the law, if he feels the existing legal framework is somehow lacking.
The ABA also noted that the Watergate scandal in the Nixon administration revealed abuses of government wiretapping. This led a Senate committee to recommend legislation to provide the government with needed authority to conduct surveillance to protect national security but also to protect against abuses of that authority.
The result was the 1978 law creating the FISA court.
The Taylor decision is expected to face tough going before the conservative U.S. 6th Circuit Court of Appeals and the U.S. Supreme Court.
Let's hope the higher courts do not allow the president to break the law.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2006
(1766)
-
▼
August
(186)
- Quote of the Day
- " Fool me Once, Shame on You...
- Spin, Spin, Spin.....BTW, Where in the World is Ka...
- “What Happened in Ohio?: A Documentary Record of T...
- 10 weeks left to change the subject.
- Rumsfeld's Ghastly Speech to the American Legion
- Clinton Ended Welfare, Not Poverty
- What Keeps Don Rumsfeld Up at Night?
- The Photo that Haunts George Allen
- Iraqi Hospitals Are War's New "Killing Fields"
- Number of Americans without Health Insurance Conti...
- Welfare Reform is Not a Success
- Rumsfeld's Remarks
- I smell an election coming...
- Reclaiming The Issues: Islamic Or Republican Fasci...
- Illusion and Reality
- I'm So Broke" JokesI'm so broke, I go to KFC and l...
- While the President pats himself on the back . . .
- An Enron Twist: convicted but not guilty?
- Bush & Katrina: Return to the Scene of the Crime
- Carter slaps down "subservient" Blair
- Whitewash
- The Cheney Presidency
- The Man Who Said Too Much
- "I am Macaca"
- Warring Over the Heart of the Party
- Read it and Weep
- Bigotry: Out in the Open
- New analysis shows Democratic takeover of House li...
- Inquiry Opened Into Israeli Use of U.S. Bombs
- McCain Backtracks
- How Sorry is Andrew Young?
- Warantless Wiretap Program in Doubt
- Bringing "Dignity" Back to the White House
- Senator Allen Not Just A "Racist"
- http://iraqforsale.org/
- McCarthyism: From 1946 to 2006
- Pluto No Longer A Planet
- Twenty-first Century Rome
- Maynard Ferguson Is Dead
- To Iran With Love
- No title
- Like Father, Like Son
- Hirsh: Bush Takes Another August Vacation While “P...
- A refrain from Groucho Marx
- Refuse to be Terrorized
- Bush in his Helmet Stands Watch on the Rhine
- Fixing the Failed U.S. Reconstruction in Iraq
- Bush Cuts and Runs At Tora Bora, Helps Bin Laden E...
- Bush Fulfills Few Promises to Post-Katrina Gulf Co...
- Senator Jokes About House Painter
- Quote of the Day
- G.O.P. Corruption? Bring In the Conservatives. - N...
- Is God an Idiot?
- At Press Conference, Bush Stays the Course
- Tax Farmers, Mercenaries and Viceroys - New York T...
- The Chimp Speaks
- Pat Buchanan . . . poco loco?!
- Interview with Gore Vidal
- A Free Pass on War Crimes?
- Bush, Iraq and the "soul" of our nation
- Five Years After 9/11, Fear Finally Strikes Out - ...
- Whatever's Best For Holy Joe
- Why Do We Have A Democracy?
- Putting Humpty Dumpty together again
- Tiptoeing into the future.
- Why the Iraqis aren't as grateful as W would like...
- The Neo-Colonialist
- Bush Contemplates Rebirth of Dictatorship for Iraq
- Washpo Misses the Point on NSA Ruling
- Duelling Pageants
- "K" , like in Kings.
- Effective anti-terrorism enforcement or more poor ...
- Wages, Wealth and Politics - New York TimesThe New...
- It's Time to Censure a Lawless President
- Want Some Freedom Fries wit dat?
- Israel's debacle, courtesy of Bush
- No title
- In the NSA Case, a Judge Says No to King George
- What Happens When You Sell Your Soul To The Devil
- This Gang Can't Shoot Straight
- You Go, Girls.
- No Kings In America
- Fox News Airs Suggestion for "Muslim-Only" Airport...
- Another Turning Point in Iraq
- George Allen: Racist? Check. Swiftboating Draft Do...
- Pavlov's dogs of terror
- Terrorism
- Bush Out To Luncheon On Iraq
- You say "Macaca," I say "Mo' Caca"
- Neocon Dreams, American Nightmares
- Spinning Old Threats Into New Fears
- IF elections are still legal in November....
- Poll: Seven Dwarfs more famous than Supreme Court
- Interview with Seymour Hersh
- No title
- The Pols Who Cried Wolf
- A Distant Mirror - New York TimesThe New York Time...
- No title
- Unholy Alliance
-
▼
August
(186)
No comments:
Post a Comment